Minnesota Winter Car Insurance: What Covers a Crash, Deer Strike, or Hail Damage?

Updated November 6, 2026

Matrix of five Minnesota winter driving scenarios showing coverage that may apply: icy-road crash and rear-end use collision and liability; deer strike and hail use comprehensive; injuries go to PIP first.

Updated October 2026. General information; your policy and insurer decide how a claim is handled.

The short answer: In Minnesota, damage to your own car from an icy-road crash is usually a collision claim; hitting a deer or hail damage is usually a comprehensive claim; damage you cause to someone else's car is covered by your liability; and injuries are paid first by personal injury protection (PIP), regardless of fault. Collision and comprehensive are optional, so check you have them, and know your deductibles, before winter.

Five winter scenarios: which coverage may apply

The matrix at the top of this page and the table below show which coverage may apply, subject to policy terms. This is general guidance, not a claim decision.

Minnesota winter driving scenarios and coverage that may apply
ScenarioYour vehicle damageOther party's vehicle or propertyInjuries
You slide on ice into a guardrailCollisionYour property damage liability (for the guardrail)PIP
You hit a deerComprehensiveUsually nonePIP
Hail dents your parked carComprehensiveNot applicableNot applicable
You rear-end another car on a slick roadCollisionYour property damage liabilityPIP; your bodily injury liability if the other person's claim meets legal thresholds
Another driver slides into youThe other driver's liability, or your collisionThe other driver's liability coveragePIP first; then the other driver's liability or your underinsured motorist coverage

Coverage definitions follow the Minnesota Department of Commerce and Minnesota's No-Fault Act. Have your agent or insurer confirm how your policy applies.

The scenarios in more detail

Sliding on ice

Weather does not change who pays. If your car hits another vehicle, a guardrail, a curb or a snowbank, damage to your car falls under collision, minus your deductible. Damage you cause to someone else's property falls under your property damage liability, and that claim can affect your future premiums. Minnesota's minimum property damage limit is only $10,000 per accident.

Hitting a deer

Hitting an animal is generally covered by comprehensive, not collision. One common wrinkle: if you swerve to avoid a deer and hit a tree or another car instead, insurers usually treat that as a collision claim. Safety officials generally advise not swerving sharply for a deer, because the swerve can be more dangerous than the impact.

Hail on a parked car

Hail damage to your car is a comprehensive claim. Because hail can hit thousands of Twin Cities vehicles in one storm, comprehensive claims were the biggest driver of Minnesota's recent auto insurance increases, according to the Minneapolis Fed. The same storms damage roofs; see our Twin Cities hail guide for the home side.

Injuries

Your PIP pays you and your passengers' medical bills and certain other losses first, no matter who caused the crash, up to its limits (minimum $20,000 medical and $20,000 non-medical per person). Our Minnesota no-fault explainer covers what PIP does and does not pay.

A deductible reminder

Collision and comprehensive each have their own deductible, and they can be different amounts. If your comprehensive deductible is $1,000 and the deer damage is $1,400, the claim pays about $400. Some policies offer lower comprehensive deductibles or full glass coverage. Our guide to deductibles explains the trade-off with your premium.

What to document after an incident

  • Get to a safe place first; call 911 if anyone is hurt or a vehicle is blocking traffic.
  • Photograph the vehicles, the road conditions, the location and any animal or debris, if it is safe to do so.
  • Exchange names, insurance details and vehicle information with any other driver.
  • Note the date, time and weather, and keep towing and repair receipts.
  • Report the claim to your insurer promptly, following your policy's requirements. Commerce has more on what to do after an accident and auto storm damage.

Policy review before winter

Before-winter auto insurance checklist (free to print and share with credit to BetterSured)
DoneCheck
☐Do you have collision and comprehensive on each car you'd want repaired?
☐What are your collision and comprehensive deductibles in dollars?
☐Are your liability limits above the 30/60/10 minimum, and enough for your assets?
☐Do you have rental reimbursement and towing or roadside coverage?
☐Is your insurer's claim number and app saved on your phone?
☐Is your proof of insurance in the car or on your phone?

A safe-driving note

Insurance pays for damage; it can't prevent it. Slow down on ice, leave extra following distance, watch for deer at dawn and dusk, and keep a winter kit in the car. Avoiding a claim also keeps it off your record.

Compare auto quotes before winter

If you are reviewing coverage before winter, BetterSured reads the declarations page you upload so quotes match your current limits and deductibles, then vetted local independent brokers compete to quote that coverage. Brokers pay BetterSured for these requests, your details go only to the brokers who quote you, and a lower price is not guaranteed.

Related guides